On Monday, the Associated Press called it: California voters rejected Proposition 40. The measure would have charged every billionaire living in the state on Jan. 1, 2026, a one-time tax of 5% of their net worth. The AP made the call six days after Election Day. The tax was trailing about 52.8% to 47.2%. Counties are still counting ballots, and the state hasn't certified the results. The health care workers' union SEIU-UHW wrote the measure. The union projected it would raise about $100 billion over five years. Most of that money would have covered federal health care cuts. A Hoover Institution paper estimated it would raise only about $30 billion. Opponents gave about $378 million to defeat it and back two rival measures. The Yes side raised $33.5 million. Google co-founder Sergey Brin gave about $102 million of that opposition money. He also moved out of state.
Billionaire Money Bought This Result
Backers say a flood of billionaire money beat the tax, and they plan to bring it back in 2028.
The other side spent its way to a win. Dave Regan, president of SEIU-UHW, called the billionaires' spending "incredibly corrosive and corrupting to our democracy and our political system." The San Francisco Chronicle says no campaign against a California ballot measure has cost more since at least 1999. Yousef Baig, California Voices editor at CalMatters, wrote that "our political system is suffocated by money."
The billionaires misled voters. On election night, Rep. Ro Khanna (D-Calif.) told reporters that billionaires "lied" about the tax. He said they "would be as well off as they were on Labor Day if they had to pay this 5% tax." UC Berkeley economist Emmanuel Saez helped design the measure. He says it "can be easily structured to avoid losing any control rights" over founders' companies.
They'll try again in 2028. SEIU-UHW says it will bring the tax back in 2028 if the Legislature "fails to deliver a real solution" for health care. "That's not a hypothetical. That's our plan," Regan said. Khanna said the billionaires are "not going to get away with it in 2028." Lorena Gonzalez is president of the California Federation of Labor Unions. She says the loss puts more pressure on state and federal lawmakers to replace federal Medicaid cuts. Those cuts are forecast to cost about 2 million Californians their health insurance.
Voters Saw a Reckless Experiment and Said No
Opponents say voters understood the tax would hurt California's economy and its budget.
Voters made the right call. Abby Lunardini is a spokesperson for Building a Better California, the main committee against the tax. "It was a lose-lose for California, and voters clearly agreed," she said. The No campaign called Prop 40 "a reckless experiment conducted on our state's economy with little regard for the harms it would cause."
The tax drove billionaires away before the vote. Brin and fellow Google co-founder Larry Page started cutting ties with California before the Jan. 1 residency date. A Hoover Institution paper estimated that nearly 30% of the tax base had already left. That paper put the tax's net value at negative $38.9 billion after counting lost income taxes. The state takes in an estimated $3 billion a year from billionaires, about 1% of its revenue. Opponents say the measure has permanently hurt that revenue.
It would have scared off founders. Nic Carter, a general partner at the venture firm Castle Island Ventures, warned about the message it sent. "You're signaling to the entrepreneur class that you consider them a resource to be plundered," he told TechCrunch.
Tax the Rich, but Do It Nationally
California's governor and his allies say the goal is right, but one state can't tax billionaires on its own.
A state tax lets billionaires leave. Gov. Gavin Newsom warned the tax would push wealthy residents out of California. He wants a national minimum tax on net worth above $100 million instead. He called Sen. Bernie Sanders' focus on inequality "spot-on." But he said "on this issue, we fundamentally disagree." Newsom also endorsed Prop 42, which would ban future wealth taxes in California. Prop 42 was leading 51.6% to 48.4% Monday evening, and the AP hadn't called it.
A one-time tax doesn't fix the budget. Planned Parenthood of California, the California Medical Association and the California Teachers Association opposed it too. Newsom, Planned Parenthood and the teachers' union said a one-time tax wouldn't solve the state's money problems. Opponents also worried about how the state would split the money. They feared a mass exodus of wealthy taxpayers would hurt the state budget.
Democrats fighting each other helped sink it. The California Democratic Party and the state's labor federation backed Prop 40. Khanna called himself and Newsom "polar opposites" on it. Supporters ran ads against Newsom in New Hampshire, New Mexico and Virginia, which vote early in the 2028 Democratic primary. USC economist John Matsusaka said before the vote that the split mattered. "When your tribe is arguing, people start to listen to the counterarguments," he said.
Where This Lands
Voters said no by about six points, and counties are still counting ballots. Backers like Regan and Khanna blame billionaire money and promise to come back in 2028. Opponents say voters rejected a reckless tax that had already pushed billionaires out. Newsom says Congress, not California, should tax billionaires. Prop 42, which was leading Monday evening, could make a 2028 rerun much harder. Younger voters mostly backed the tax. About 7 in 10 voters 65 and older voted against it.
Sources
- Associated Press via FOX 5 New York: https://www.fox5ny.com/news/prop-40-fails-california-voters-reject-billionaire-wealth-tax
- CalMatters: https://calmatters.org/politics/elections/2026/11/prop-40-billionaire-tax-defeated/
- NPR: https://www.npr.org/2026/11/09/g-s1-151625/california-billionaire-tax-referendum
- Newsweek: https://www.newsweek.com/california-voters-reject-billionaire-tax-exposing-democratic-divide-12691714
- ABC News: https://abcnews.com/Politics/californias-prop-40-billionaires-tax-measure-rejected-ap/story?id=137999519
- TechCrunch: https://techcrunch.com/2026/11/09/californias-proposed-billionaire-tax-fails-to-pass/
- HuffPost: https://www.huffpost.com/entry/biggest-ballot-measure-california-billionaire-tax_n_6af1fd82e4b08067d8496f03
- CalMatters commentary: https://calmatters.org/commentary/2026/11/billionaire-tax-failure-money-politics/
- CalMatters (Newsom and Prop 42): https://calmatters.org/politics/2026/10/newsom-tax-propositions-november-election/
- GV Wire: https://gvwire.com/2026/11/09/california-voters-reject-prop-40-billionaire-tax/