New York Gov. Kathy Hochul vetoed the Food Safety and Chemical Disclosure Act on Friday. The bill would have banned Red No. 3, potassium bromate and propylparaben in food made or sold in New York. Those additives show up in things like sprinkles, cereal, pizza crust and tortillas. The bill also dealt with a federal rule called GRAS, short for "generally recognized as safe." Under GRAS, companies can decide an ingredient is safe without telling the FDA. The bill would have made those companies send their safety evidence to the state. The state would then publish it. Assemblymember Anna Kelles and state Sen. Brian Kavanagh sponsored it, and the Legislature passed it in April. Lawmakers said it would have been the first law of its kind in the country. California has already passed a law banning all three additives, starting in January 2027.

Hochul Says the Bill Would Raise Prices and Washington Should Set Food Rules

Her office says the bill would raise grocery prices, and that Washington should set food rules.

The bill would raise prices on staples, her office says. "When it comes to New York's famous pizza and bagels, the only thing that should rise is the dough, not the cost," a Hochul spokesperson said. Her office called the bill's goal "laudable." But it said the law "would put New York businesses at a competitive disadvantage, force New York consumers to pay even more for staple groceries and raise costs for taxpayers."

Washington should regulate food ingredients, her office says. It noted that the FDA has already banned Red No. 3 in food. That ban takes effect in January 2027. The FDA also proposed new transparency rules for food additives in August. Hochul "urges the FDA to continue its ongoing review and strengthen its oversight of food ingredients," her office said.

Bakers can already pick bromate-free flour, her office says. Her office said a ban on bromated flour would force most of the state's pizza and bagel makers to change their recipes. It said flour without bromate is already easy to find, so bakers and small business owners can choose for themselves.

Food Industry Groups Say the Bill Costs Too Much and Doesn't Make Food Safer

Industry groups say the bill adds paperwork and raises prices without making food any safer.

Households would pay about $620 more a year, they say. Policy Navigation Group did that study, and the American Beverage Association paid for it. The industry-backed Food Ingredient Safety Coalition released it in April. Kyle Wallach, government affairs director at the Business Council of New York State, said the bill "would negatively impact both businesses and consumers without improving food safety at all."

The state would have no deadline to finish its reviews, they say. Allison Cooke, a regulatory affairs director at the International Food Additives Council, wrote that companies would have to file technical reports "potentially thousands of pages long." She said companies couldn't sell affected products until the state reviewed them, and "there is no deadline at all." She warned that some companies might skip New York. "What would New Yorkers get for that money? Absolutely nothing," she wrote.

Some small business owners sided with industry. The Business Council and the New York State Conference of Teamsters put out a list of more than 300 small businesses that oppose the bill. On Thursday, Albany restaurant owner Jordan Cambron joined them near the Capitol to urge a veto. He uses bromated flour in some dishes and said he may have to raise prices if his costs keep climbing.

Sponsors and Consumer Groups Say Companies Should Share the Safety Evidence They Have

Supporters say industry inflated the cost and that New York could have acted where Washington hasn't.

Households would pay no more than $28, they say. Researchers from Tufts University and the Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI), a consumer group, did the math this week. They said $28 is the most it would cost even if companies passed every dollar on to shoppers. They said it would be mostly a one-time cost. "Big Food's $620-a-year price tag doesn't hold up to the light," said Meghan Enslow, a CSPI senior policy associate.

Companies should share the safety tests they say they've already done. "Food companies insist they've done the safety testing already. New York lawmakers were just asking them to show their work," said Jensen Jose, CSPI's senior regulatory counsel. He added: "At a time when Secretary Kennedy, President Trump and Congress have failed to deliver meaningful food safety reform, New York had a chance to lead the nation." Brian Ronholm, Consumer Reports' director of food policy, said the veto lets manufacturers keep approving their own additives without oversight. "It also signals that corporate interests take precedence over public health," he said.

Bromate-free flour costs bakers the same, Kelles says. Kelles has a Ph.D. in nutrition and once worked at a commercial bakery that made 25,000 bagels a night. She said she found one brand's 50-pound bags of flour, with and without bromate, selling for the same price. She also said most members of the American Bakers Association already avoid potassium bromate. "I'm going to reintroduce this bill," Kelles said. "I really hope that (the governor) joins us."

Where This Lands

The three additives stay legal in New York for now. Hochul says the bill would raise grocery prices and that the FDA should write food rules. Industry groups say it would add paperwork and cost without making food safer. Sponsors and consumer groups say industry inflated the cost. They want companies to share the safety evidence the companies say they already have. Kelles says she'll reintroduce the bill, and CSPI's Jose expects lawmakers to take it up again when they return to Albany in January.

Sources