A Washington Post-ABC News-Ipsos poll released May 3 puts Trump's disapproval at 62% and approval at 37% — the highest disapproval of either of his terms. A Pew Research survey from the same week has approval at 34%, the lowest of his second term. Reuters/Ipsos has him at 34% as well. Iran war disapproval is 66%; cost-of-living disapproval is 76%. The midterms are six months away.

1. The Bottom Is Falling Out (Pew, WaPo, Silver, Enten)

Multiple independent polls landed within days of each other. They all say the same thing.

The numbers are not noise. They are converging. Three high-quality polls hit Trump at 34-37% approval within a week: WaPo-ABC-Ipsos at 37/62, Pew at 34, Reuters/Ipsos at 34. Nate Silver's polling average has Trump at a second-term low of -18.8 net approval, with cost-of-living net approval at -41.5. CNN chief data analyst Harry Enten said it plainly: Trump's approval is "down there with the Titanic."

The personal collapse is the deeper story. Pew's same survey shows the share of Americans calling Trump "honest" fell from 42% to 34%; "mentally sharp" from 55% to 44%; "a good role model" from 34% to 26%. The number who think he "keeps his promises" has dropped from 51% right after the 2024 election to 38% now. 56% say the overall level of ethics and honesty in the federal government has fallen during his term. These are not issue ratings — they're the underlying brand.

The coalition is cracking where it matters. Republicans hold at 85%. But Republican-leaning independents have slipped to a second-term low of 56%, and all independents to 25%. Democrats now hold a 5-point advantage on the generic House ballot, up from 2 points in February and October 2025. The base is intact; the people who put Trump over the top in 2024 are not.

2. The War Did This (WaPo analysis)

Trump's Iran war is as unpopular as Iraq was in 2006 and Vietnam was in the early 1970s, and it got there in two months instead of years.

Sixty-one percent of Americans say using military force against Iran was a "mistake." That includes 91% of Democrats, 71% of independents, and 19% of Republicans. Just 19% say the war has been successful; 39% say it hasn't been; 41% say it's too soon to tell. Disapproval of Trump's handling of the war specifically is 66%.

The pace is unprecedented. By Gallup's measure, 59% of Americans called the Iraq War a mistake in mid-2006 — three years after it began. Vietnam reached similar disapproval in the early 1970s, after years of casualties and television coverage. Trump's Iran war reached the same disapproval level in roughly two months. WaPo's framing: it took years for Iraq to land where Iran is now.

The administration kept expanding the Iran footprint. Trump's "Project Freedom" Strait of Hormuz operation — guided-missile destroyers, aircraft, and 15,000 service members — was announced May 3, the same day the WaPo-ABC-Ipsos poll dropped. The public is not buying the "war has been terminated" framing the White House sent to Congress to skirt the 60-day War Powers clock.

3. No, It's The Cost Of Living (Reuters/Ipsos read)

Iran is the headline, but the bigger driver is gas, groceries, and the part of the inflation story Trump promised to fix on day one.

Cost of living polls worse than the war. WaPo-ABC-Ipsos: 76% disapprove of Trump's handling of cost of living, with only 23% approving — a wider gap than any other issue measured. Trump's net approval on cost of living, in Silver's average, is -41.5.

The slide is economics first, war second. Reuters/Ipsos attributed Trump's second-term-low approval to "economic uncertainty" alongside the war, with both reinforcing each other — the Iran conflict is itself driving gas prices, which feeds back into the inflation number. The campaign promise that won swing voters in 2024 was specifically about lowering grocery and gas costs. The numbers say that promise has not been kept.

The "keeps his promises" trait is collapsing for the same reason. Pew's tracking shows that score going from 51% post-election to 43% in August 2025 to 38% now — among the steepest drops on any personal trait. The drop tracks the pump price more than the drone strike. The Iran war intensified an existing economic disappointment; it did not create one.

4. Polls Are Fake (Trump, MAGA)

Trump won in 2016 when the polls said he wouldn't, and again in 2024 when polls showed a coin flip. Why should anyone trust 2026 numbers either?

The "fake polls" frame has a track record on the right. The 2016 and 2024 elections both saw polling either wrong or close to wrong in Trump's favor, and the campaign has used that history to dismiss every unfavorable result since. Earlier in 2026 Trump publicly attacked NYT/Siena polling as "heavily skewed toward Democrats" and said he would add the Times to a pending lawsuit.

The Republican base is still fiercely loyal. Trump's approval among self-identified Republicans is 85% — a strong intra-party number even at this point in a second term. From inside MAGA, the case is straightforward: the Democrats and independents in these polls were never going to vote Trump anyway, the base is intact, and a midterm without Trump on the ballot is not a referendum on him.

Where This Lands

The strongest case for the doomsayers is consistency: three independent pollsters hit Trump in the 34-37% range in the same week, the personal-traits collapse is real, and the swing groups he won in 2024 are no longer with him. The strongest case for the dismissers is recent history: Trump-era polls have been wrong in his favor twice already, his base hasn't moved, and a midterm is structurally different from a presidential year.

Sources