Mississippi still doesn't know who won its Senate seat. The AP count, which ABC News uses, had Democrat Scott Colom ahead of Republican Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith by 65 votes as of 5:35 p.m. ET Wednesday. About 95% of the expected vote was in. The Mississippi Free Press reported late Wednesday afternoon that Decision Desk HQ had counted more ballots and showed Colom up by nearly 2,000. Neither had called the race, and NBC News listed it as too close to call. About 3,600 mail ballots are still out, and nobody knows how many affidavit ballots are left. Affidavit ballots are what other states call provisional ballots. Trump won Mississippi with 61% in 2024. The state hasn't elected a Democrat to the Senate since 1982. Democrats already hold the Senate majority without this seat.

1. The Uncounted Ballots Will Put Colom Over (Colom and Democrats)

Colom says the uncounted ballots favor him, and his lawyers are there to make sure every one gets counted.

Colom says he's already won. "This is our election. We've won it," Colom said Wednesday. "I'm confident once the process lays out where we are, where the ballots are, we're going to win." Colom is a district attorney. He'd be Mississippi's first Black U.S. senator since Reconstruction. He said his campaign is "prepared to litigate" and has "an army of lawyers." Democratic election lawyer Marc Elias posted that Colom "is going to be the next Senator from Mississippi." Elias said his firm is leading the legal effort.

Democrats say many of their voters were wrongly pushed to affidavit ballots. Democracy Docket reported that Mississippi Secretary of State Michael Watson, a Republican, flagged about 230,000 registrations as "inactive." Elias founded Democracy Docket. Those voters could still vote, but only by affidavit ballot. The state Democratic Party's hotline got about 2,000 calls Tuesday, NBC reported. Many callers said they were told to use affidavit ballots even though they thought they were registered. Mikell Bolden, the party's executive director, said the secretary of state's website had crashed, so voters couldn't check their status. "Everything is on the line right now for this state," Bolden said.

The party already went to court once. On Tuesday night, the state Democratic Party sued in DeSoto County over late-opening polls, ballot shortages and long lines. The suit said one voter waiting in line lost consciousness and was taken to the hospital. The party dropped the suit Wednesday morning.

2. Every Ballot Must Pass State Rules First (Hyde-Smith and Republicans)

Hyde-Smith's campaign says the remaining ballots must be checked under state law, and it expects her to come out ahead.

Hyde-Smith expects to keep her seat. "I assure you I will continue to be your U.S. Senator," she told supporters Tuesday night. She also said, "We still don't have all the votes in, so we're not calling all of it tonight." On Wednesday, her campaign said "the margin is measured in just dozens of votes." It said it's confident she'll win once every legally cast vote is counted. When reporters asked about her Tuesday remarks, Colom said, "Bless her heart."

Her campaign wants every ballot checked first. Her campaign said "thousands of outstanding ballots, including affidavit and absentee ballots," still "must be processed and verified under Mississippi law." An affidavit ballot counts only if the voter was registered in that precinct and both the voter and the poll worker signed the envelope. Voters who didn't show ID at the polls also have to bring acceptable ID within five business days. "We are committed to ensuring that every single lawful ballot is accurately counted," said Joanna Rodriguez, a spokeswoman for the National Republican Senatorial Committee.

3. Mississippi Never Wrote a Recount Law (Election-Law Experts)

Election-law experts say the state left no clear way to settle a race this close, so it could end up in court or in the Senate.

Mississippi has no recount law at all. The secretary of state's office told ABC News that candidates can't ask for a recount, and none happens automatically. Ben Griffith, an election lawyer who teaches at the University of Mississippi, told NBC that state law also has no way to contest a U.S. Senate general election. In February, a bill from Republican state Rep. Timmy Ladner died in a House committee. It would have required recounts in races decided by 250 votes or 1%.

Losing candidates can still fight ballot by ballot. "That's not to say a losing candidate in Mississippi has no remedy," wrote Derek Muller, an election-law professor at Notre Dame. Candidates can sue over whether specific ballots should count. They can also ask to examine a county's ballot boxes. Griffith said examining ballot boxes in all 82 counties in nine days is "beyond the scope of feasibility."

The Senate itself could decide. The Constitution lets each chamber judge its own members' elections. Muller noted that the Senate has that power. That means the Senate could end up deciding the race, Democracy Docket wrote. In 1975, the Senate declared a New Hampshire seat vacant after a deadlocked recount fight.

Where This Lands

Colom leads in the uncalled count, and he says the affidavit ballots will carry him. Hyde-Smith's campaign says every one of those ballots has to pass Mississippi's rules first, and it expects her to win. Mail ballots postmarked by Election Day can arrive until 5 p.m. on Nov. 10. Counties must certify their results by Nov. 13, and the secretary of state declares the result on Dec. 3. Mississippi has no recount law, so any fight would play out in court, ballot by ballot. If that doesn't settle it, the new Senate could take it up when it meets Jan. 3, 2027.

Sources