Fiona, the Cincinnati Zoo's famous Nile hippo, died on Thursday. She was born six weeks early in 2017, weighing just 29 pounds. Her fight to survive made her a viral star. On Nov. 8, she swallowed a knit hat. The zoo says a child tossed the hat in the air, and a ceiling fan flung it through a 1-foot gap above the viewing windows. Keepers tried round-the-clock care, laxative-like supplements and a vibration plate borrowed from a horse farm. She died while recovering from a procedure. On Friday, the zoo said the hat was stuck deep in her small intestine, where no scope could reach it. The zoo's posts drew nearly 300,000 comments.

The Family Should Pay for This

This camp says someone's carelessness killed Fiona, and someone should answer for it.

A lot of fans want charges. The top comment on the zoo's Instagram post has more than 31,000 likes. It reads, "So we're pressing charges on whoever threw that hat in there, right?" Political commentator Tomi Lahren wrote, "Parents need to be fined an incredible amount." Other fans want the family banned for life or sent the vet bill. Another commenter wrote, "Just because it was a child doesn't make it alright."

Some don't buy the accident story. One commenter wrote, "You'd have to throw something pretty high to get it over the glass."

Zoos Need to Stop Things From Falling Into Exhibits

This camp says Fiona's death was predictable, because it keeps happening at zoos.

A hippo vet knows of at least a dozen similar cases. Dr. Gabriella Flacke is a Zoo Miami veterinarian who specializes in hippos and consulted on Fiona's case. She told CNN she knows of "at least a dozen or more other cases in zoos around the world." She said exhibits that bring visitors close make it "possible for things to fall in or things to get thrown in." The AP lists other cases, including a German zoo's polar bear that swallowed a jacket in 2014.

Fans want the enclosures fixed. Some social media users say the zoo "needs to better protect its animals." One commenter wrote, "Either make the zoo 18+ or human-proof the enclosures." After Harambe the gorilla was shot in 2016, the same zoo reopened his exhibit with a higher, reinforced barrier. The zoo hasn't said whether it will close the gap above Fiona's windows.

It Was a Fluke Accident, and the Keepers Did All They Could

This camp says nobody is to blame and the staff deserve sympathy.

The zoo says it was a fluke. Michelle Curley, the zoo's spokesperson, said, "We probably couldn't make that happen again if we tried." Melissa Howerton, an executive vice president at the Association of Zoos and Aquariums, called it a "tragic and unusual accident."

The zoo's vet says surgery would have killed her. Dr. Mike Wenninger, the zoo's director of animal health, said surgery "would have been a death sentence for her." Zoo Director Dave Jenike said the care team "did everything possible." A local wildlife group, Dino Buddies, asked people to give the staff "compassion, kindness, and grace."

Visitors can help stop the next one. Dr. Jennifer Quammen, president of the American Veterinary Medical Association, said, "We all share a responsibility to help protect animals from potentially dangerous objects." The zoo posted the same plea on Nov. 16, while Fiona was sick.

Charges probably aren't coming. WCPO, a Cincinnati TV station, reports that Ohio's animal-cruelty law requires a malicious or willful act. WCPO says nothing shows the child meant any harm.

Zoos Should Rethink Breeding Hippos

This camp says Fiona's fame shouldn't stop us from asking why she lived in a zoo.

A wildlife writer asks whether zoos should keep breeding hippos. Zac Mills, a wildlife photographer, writes for The Wildlife Collective, a conservation newsletter on Substack. "The question is whether we should continue creating more Fionas," he wrote on Friday. He asked whether "we are simply using conservation as a justification for something we enjoy." He said he isn't attacking the Cincinnati Zoo, and that her keepers "clearly cared deeply."

Where This Lands

Thousands of fans want the child's family charged, fined or banned. Cincinnati's WCPO reports that Ohio law makes charges unlikely. A Zoo Miami hippo vet says things often fall into exhibits that put visitors up close. Fans want the gap above the windows closed. The zoo and two national animal groups call it an accident. The zoo says no scope or surgery could safely reach the hat. A wildlife writer is asking whether zoos should keep breeding hippos at all. The zoo's Hippo Cove is closed through the weekend.

Sources