President Donald Trump said on Thursday that he'd given "a Complete and Total Pardon" to Pete Rose, baseball's all-time hits leader, who died in 2024. The post didn't name a crime, and a White House official pointed to Rose's tax case. In 1990, Rose pleaded guilty to filing false tax returns and served five months in prison. He accepted a lifetime ban from baseball in 1989 after an investigation found he bet on the Reds while he played for and managed them. In May 2025, less than a month after Commissioner Rob Manfred met with Trump, MLB reinstated Rose, which made him eligible for the Hall of Fame. Trump's post said Rose got 4,256 hits "in a Season." That's his career total, and reports say the post was later fixed. An MLB spokesman declined to comment to Reuters.

Rose Paid His Debt, and Baseball Treated Him Badly

Trump says Rose went through decades of punishment for gambling that's legal now. The family's lawyer calls the pardon a kind gesture that came too late.

He's been punished enough. Earlier this month at the White House, Trump said Rose "shouldn't have done it, but he went through 40 years of hell, and they should be giving him a pardon." Trump has made this argument for more than a decade. In 2015, he posted, "He's paid the price. So ridiculous - let him in!" His pardon post said Rose was "treated terribly by Major League Baseball" and added, "Politics, I guess!"

Sports betting is legal now. "He was caught gambling, and now it's legal," Trump said at that same briefing. He added that Rose "was gambling on his own team," not against it, and said "that's different." UFC CEO Dana White, who joined Trump at the briefing, said, "I think it's fair to pardon Pete Rose."

The family's lawyer wishes it had come sooner. Jeffrey Lenkov, a lawyer who has represented the Rose family, told Reuters the pardon was a "benevolent gesture." But, he said, "it would have been better to have occurred when he was alive." He says he'll tell Hall of Fame voters that Rose "paid back any debt."

But a Pardon Can't Get Rose Into the Hall of Fame

Sportswriters say the pardon leaves the Hall of Fame vote where it was, and they question what it's even for.

Pardons don't count for the Hall of Fame. "No presidential pardon has any impact on a player's eligibility or process for being inducted into the Hall of Fame," wrote Gordon Wittenmyer of the Cincinnati Enquirer. He wrote that the Hall is separate from MLB, and that a president can't pardon anyone from a league's punishment.

He still probably won't get in. USA Today wrote that Rose's chances "appear limited," because the Hall's committee tends to follow the baseball writers, who kept out Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens, two stars tied to performance-enhancing drugs. Rose would need 12 votes from the 16-member panel.

The tax case isn't why baseball banned him. David Murphy, a Philadelphia Inquirer sports columnist, asked, "For what offense is Trump completely and totally pardoning Rose?" He noted that "baseball didn't ban Rose because he didn't pay taxes on his gambling winnings." He also asked why Trump waited until two years after Rose died.

Rose Wasn't a Victim, and a Pardon Doesn't Clean Up His Record

Some sportswriters say Rose's own choices got him banned and sent to prison. They say his record includes worse than a tax case.

He brought this on himself. Kevin S. Aldridge, the Cincinnati Enquirer's opinion and engagement editor, answered Trump's "Politics, I guess!" with "No, Mr. President. Consequences, actually." He says Rose deserves recognition as a player. But he wrote that the gambling and the prison time "weren't political persecutions," and that a pardon can't "erase Rose's choices."

His record goes beyond the tax case. Rose sued John Dowd, the lawyer who led baseball's investigation, for defamation in 2016. In 2017, Dowd's lawyers filed a sworn statement from a woman who said Rose first called her in 1973, when she was 14 or 15, and that he began a sexual relationship with her "before my 16th birthday." Rose said in court papers that it began in 1975 and that he believed she was 16, Ohio's age of consent. He denied committing statutory rape and was never charged. Craig Calcaterra, who writes the daily newsletter Cup of Coffee, noted that a federal pardon couldn't have covered that anyway, because any charges would have come from the state.

A pardon doesn't make him innocent. Christina Kahrl, the San Francisco Chronicle's sports editor, wrote, "A presidential pardon doesn't erase a simple historical fact about Pete Rose: #StillGuilty, of all of it and probably more besides."

Where This Lands

Trump says Rose went through 40 years of hell for gambling that's legal now, and the family's lawyer will tell Hall of Fame voters he paid his debt. Sportswriters at the Enquirer and USA Today say the pardon has no bearing on the Hall. The Inquirer's Murphy asks what crime it even covers, since baseball didn't ban Rose over taxes. Aldridge and Kahrl say Rose's own choices cost him, and a pardon doesn't change that. The Hall's committee votes in December 2027, and the earliest Rose could get in is July 2028.

Sources