On ESPN's "First Take" on Wednesday, host Stephen A. Smith turned to the league's Black stars. "These white brothers can play, they can play. They can win a championship. This is the NBA! Y'all gonna let them win a championship?" he said. By "white brothers," he meant the Lakers' core of Luka Doncic, Austin Reaves and Walker Kessler. Smith has made this point since July. Last week on Mad Dog Sports Radio, he said he'd never "seen an NBA team with its top three players being white win a championship." ESPN analyst Jay Williams called him out Wednesday. Smith wrote back that night, "I said what I said and I meant what I meant." In a clip posted Thursday, former NBA star Kevin Garnett told him, "You got to apologize." Smith answered, "I ain't apologizing for it." No outlet has reported a statement from ESPN.
Smith Is Just Stating History and Daring Today's Stars
Smith says he stated history and dared today's stars to stop the Lakers. In July, his former "First Take" partner Skip Bayless said Smith's original comments weren't racist.
Smith says he's just stating history. "All I said was the three top dudes on a basketball team being white has never led an NBA team to a championship since the days of George Mikan," he told Garnett. "That is a fact. Nobody can dispute that." Smith wrote back to Williams, "I don't hear you denying that what I said is true."
He says he's trying to motivate the league's stars. On the show, Smith said, "you want little motivational nuggets to nudge cats a little bit." He told Williams, "I'm talking about right now. I love this challenge to the fellas." He also said, "I'm not rooting against nobody."
Bayless said it wasn't racist. When Smith first made the argument in July, his former "First Take" partner Skip Bayless said, "That was no racist statement. That was just the gutsy, historical truth." But Bayless also said that "as right as Stephen A. is about history," the three Lakers could "shatter that mold."
Smith Is Sorting Players by Race, and a White Host Would Be Fired for It
Critics say Smith is judging players by race, which sports spent generations fighting to stop. They say a white host who said it would be fired.
Williams says it sounds like the 1930s in reverse. Williams, an ESPN analyst and former NBA player, wrote that Smith's line "sounds like something you'd hear in the 1930s or 1940s, just with the racial dynamics reversed." He added, "We spent generations fighting to ensure athletes were judged by their talent, not the color of their skin." In July, former NFL linebacker Emmanuel Acho called Smith's original comments "racist" on his show Speakeasy.
Critics say a white host would be fired for the same line. Williams asked Smith to "imagine a white analyst asking on national TV, 'Y'all really gonna let these Black quarterbacks win another Super Bowl?'" Williams added, "I get the barbershop talk. But familiarity doesn't make something right." Clay Travis, who founded OutKick and now runs Sport & State, made the same comparison. "He would never work in TV again," Travis wrote of a white host who said it. T.J. Moe of The Blaze wrote that such an analyst "would be fired, labeled racist and unemployable."
Critics want ESPN to hold Smith accountable. In July, OutKick ran a column by Bobby Burack headlined "ESPN must hold Stephen A. accountable." Last week, Burack predicted Smith "will not face any considerable backlash." One fan on X wrote, "In a rational world ESPN would fire him tonight."
The Lakers' Race Doesn't Matter, and Doncic Is Just Good
Former players say the Lakers' race doesn't matter, and Garnett says Smith should apologize.
World Peace and Holliday say the Lakers' race is beside the point. Former Lakers forward Metta World Peace wrote, "I love seeing white basketball players on the same team." In a video, he said, "We have all-Black teams, right? … Why would we not wanna see an all-white team?" Former NFL player Doc Holliday asked, "What does the fact that they're white have to do with anything? They're hooping."
Garnett says the Lakers are making Smith look crazy. "They making you look crazy," Garnett told him. "I am not asking you to back up on none of that," Garnett said. "I am saying check what you said, coz this boy doing some, he averaging 40 Stephen." Doncic is averaging 38.1 points a game, according to ClutchPoints.
Where This Lands
Smith says he stated a historical fact and dared today's stars to stop the Lakers. In July, Bayless said Smith's original comments weren't racist. Williams asked Smith to imagine a white analyst saying the same thing about Black players. Travis and Moe say that host would lose his job, and Acho called Smith's July comments racist. World Peace and Holliday say the Lakers' race doesn't matter. Garnett says the Lakers are making Smith look crazy and that he should apologize. Smith told Garnett he won't. No outlet has reported a statement from ESPN.
Sources
- California Post via Yahoo Sports: https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/media-firebrand-asks-black-players-212720163.html
- Basketball Network via Yahoo Sports: https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/sounds-something-1930s-1940s-jay-003309788.html
- The Spun via Yahoo Sports: https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/stephen-smith-doubles-down-fires-141436972.html
- Fadeaway World via Yardbarker: https://www.yardbarker.com/nba/articles/stephen_a_smith_doubles_down_on_lakers_comments_after_jay_williams_calls_him_out/s1_16751_44586194
- The Shadow League: https://theshadowleague.com/stephen-a-smith-says-black-nba-players-cant-let-white-lakers-win-championship/
- Daily Wire: https://www.dailywire.com/news/jay-williams-calls-out-stephen-a-smith-asking-the-brothers-to-stop-the-lakers
- ClutchPoints: https://clutchpoints.com/nba/los-angeles-lakers/lakers-news-kevin-garnett-calls-stephen-a-smith-wild-white-dude-rants-la
- HEAVY via Yahoo Sports: https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/stephen-smith-under-fire-alleged-213436324.html
- The Comeback: https://thecomeback.com/nba/i-dont-understand-how-thats-relevant-stephen-a-smith-sparks-outrage-with-comments-on-white-nba-players.html
- OutKick via Yahoo Sports: https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/stephen-smith-says-white-players-222348565.html
- OutKick (Bayless, July): https://www.foxnews.com/outkick-sports/skip-bayless-pushes-back-stephen-a-claim-three-white-dudes-win-nba-championship-together.amp
- OutKick (ESPN accountability, July): https://www.foxnews.com/outkick-sports/espn-hold-stephen-a-accountable-doubling-down-racist-remarks-white-basketball-players.amp
- Awful Announcing (Acho): https://awfulannouncing.com/nba/stephen-a-smith-emmanuel-acho-white-dude-central-los-angeles-lakers-racist.html
- Awful Announcing (Travis): https://awfulannouncing.com/fox/clay-travis-officially-launches-new-venture-sport-state.html
- EssentiallySports via Yardbarker: https://www.yardbarker.com/nba/articles/we_have_all_black_teams_lakers_legend_speaks_out_on_racism_in_sports_amid_stephen_a_smith_controversy/s1_17730_44586289
- BasketballNews: https://www.basketballnews.com/news/basketballnews-nba-active-news-these-white-brothers-can-play-stephen-a-smith-reacts-to-los-angeles-lakers-thirteen-two-start-after-championship-claim/