On Wednesday, as the owners meetings wrapped up in New York, MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred drew a hard line. "I can't imagine the owners ratifying a deal that does not include a cap and floor," he said. The league wants a hard cap of $258.2 million and a spending floor of $180.2 million, starting in 2028. Players have called a cap a "nonstarter" since the league proposed it in May. The current labor deal expires at 11:59 p.m. ET on Dec. 1. Reporters at ESPN and AP expect owners to lock players out after that. Manfred said they'll decide on a lockout "at the last possible moment." A lockout would freeze trades and signings and could threaten the 2027 season. The last time owners pushed for a cap, in 1994, players struck and MLB canceled the World Series.

A Cap and Floor Are the Only Way to Fix a Lopsided Game

The owners say the richest teams buy the best players, and most fans want limits.

Owners say the richest teams outspend the poorest by too much. Manfred said, "Competitive balance is a serious problem, and it needs to be addressed." The Associated Press used 2026 payrolls to calculate that the Dodgers would have to cut $174 million to get under the 2028 cap, and the Mets $108 million. MLB executive vice president Morgan Sword said, "It is truly aberrational in baseball for small markets to be successful."

Manfred says all 30 owners are behind it. "Thirty clubs are 100% unanimous in support of the proposals that have been made," he said. Milwaukee Brewers owner Mark Attanasio is one of them. His team plays in baseball's smallest media market, and it won the World Series last month. In October, Attanasio pointed to Yankees owner Hal Steinbrenner. "I saw that Hal [Steinbrenner] said he supported the league [labor] proposals in their entirety. Ditto for me," Attanasio said.

Fans want it, and it could end TV blackouts. "We are not prepared to tell 70% of our fans that they're wrong on this issue," Manfred said. The Athletic ran an informal preseason survey of more than 14,000 fans. Of those fans, 68% backed a cap and floor. MLB also says a cap is the best way to share local TV money. That would let the league end local blackouts. Sword said players "will earn more money in this system," and that "it's just a matter of just distributing the players differently across the teams."

The Cap Is a Pay Cut, and Small-Payroll Teams Just Reached the World Series

The players' union says owners want to hold down salaries to raise profits and team values.

Owners want to pay players less. Bruce Meyer, the union's interim executive director, answered Manfred on Wednesday. "They want to make more money in profits and franchise values by artificially suppressing player salaries," he said. He called the cap "a radical change to the system that would dramatically reduce overall player compensation." He said it would also "strip" players' ability "to have truly guaranteed contracts." Meyer told the Boston Globe on Tuesday that players already get 55 to 56 percent of revenue, more than the league's proposed 50-50 split. Manfred put the figure at less than 50 percent.

Small teams already win. The Brewers and Rays met in this year's World Series, and their payrolls ranked 19th and 27th. When the series opened, Meyer said "the results of these playoffs obviously further undermine" the owners' case. The union also says MLB created the blackout problem and can fix it without a cap.

Players have their own fix. They proposed a "competitive integrity tax" on teams that spend below a payroll floor. They also want a higher luxury-tax threshold and more salary arbitration. Manfred calls the union's stance "a refusal to bargain."

Bad Owners Hide Behind the Dodgers, Who'll Stay Elite Anyway

A Crossing Broad writer says the cap push lets other owners off the hook, and the Dodgers' owner says his team will stay elite.

Some owners just spend badly. Crossing Broad writer Tim Reilly argued in May that casting the Dodgers as the villain "is a PR tactic." He said it "conveniently lets a number of owners off the hook for their own business decisions and failings." He pointed to the Rays and Guardians, who win by drafting and developing players. "Big money can be spent poorly," he wrote. He also admitted "the playing field is not remotely level."

The Dodgers say they'll stay on top under any rules. Dodgers controlling owner Mark Walter said, "It's not just spending." He said the team's farm system and player development "are really big things for us." "I think on any playing field, we'll still be among the elite teams," he said. Sports Illustrated cited estimates that put the Dodgers' luxury-tax payroll at more than five times the Marlins'.

Where This Lands

Owners say a cap and floor would help lower-payroll teams compete, and they say fans agree. The union says the cap is a pay cut. It says this year's World Series, between teams with the 19th- and 27th-ranked payrolls, undercuts the owners' case. Reilly says casting the Dodgers as the villain lets other owners off the hook for their own mistakes. CBS Sports writer Dayn Perry said Manfred's "can't imagine" may be a hedge. Perry noted that Manfred used to be the league's lead negotiator and knows tough talk is a tactic. The labor deal runs out at 11:59 p.m. ET on Dec. 1.

Sources