The Game Awards announced its nominees Tuesday in a livestream hosted by Geoff Keighley, the show's creator. Rockstar's Grand Theft Auto VI got eight nominations, including Game of the Year. That's more than any other game. The game doesn't come out until Thursday. For Game of the Year, it's up against 007 First Light, Control Resonant, Phantom Blade Zero, Resident Evil Requiem and a new version of The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. The show's rules say a game qualifies if it goes on sale by 9 p.m. Pacific on Friday, November 20. A jury of more than 100 media and creator outlets picks the nominees, and the show says jurors may get early copies of games. No reviews of GTA 6 had come out as of early Wednesday, and Metacritic still listed its score as "tbd." The show names its winners December 10.
1. Nobody Has Played It, So It Shouldn't Be Nominated
Many fans call it rigged, and a gaming writer says it makes the awards mean less.
A lot of fans think it's rigged. On X, the user @HurtboxTV wrote, "Your blatant rigging is so obvious." Another X user, Uncleanly_Zeus, mocked "detailed nominations" for "games that haven't even been played by anyone."
Players can't judge it, so the award means less. Gurugamer writer John Drake wrote that nominating a game before release makes it "impossible for the broader player base or even many jurors" to judge the whole game. He wrote that "the awards lose weight as a meaningful measure of the year in gaming."
2. But Some Jurors Got Early Copies, and the Rules Allow It
Keighley says the show's dates never moved, and other defenders say the jury got to play it early.
The show didn't change its dates for Rockstar. Keighley told Variety that "everyone thought that we had changed our dates to accommodate 'GTA.'" He said, "actually our dates have been very set every year." The game comes out one day before the cutoff.
Some of the voters have already played it. ComicBook.com writer Justin Joy wrote that "several outlets are already playing the game, and The Game Awards is using these to determine its nominations." He wrote that the nomination makes sense, even with no reviews out yet. On Reddit, one user defended the picks by pointing to Rockstar's track record.
3. Still, the Jury Should Explain How It Judged the Game
These critics want the jury to explain how it judged the game and why it passed over others.
Nobody knows how much of the game jurors saw. ThePCEnthusiast writer Peter Paul wrote that no one outside the process knows how many jurors got copies or how long they played. He thinks Rockstar's reputation may be winning the game some of its nominations, especially Best Narrative. He wrote, "An eligibility deadline tells us when a game can compete. It doesn't tell us whether the jury has seen enough to judge it."
The jury passed over a game people did play. Crimson Desert came out in March and won PC Game of the Year at the Golden Joystick Awards, a fan vote. It got just one Game Awards nomination, for Best Community Support. Paul wrote that it belonged on the Game of the Year list ahead of 007 First Light and Control Resonant. Drake also cites the Crimson Desert snub, and he says the jury seems to favor big, hyped games over ones that are already out.
A remake made the top list instead. The Ocarina of Time nominee is a Switch 2 remake of a 1998 game. Drake wrote that a remake in the top category "blurs the line" between new games and updated classics.
Where This Lands
Fans on X call the nominations rigged, and Drake says nominating an unreleased game makes the awards mean less. Keighley says the show's dates never moved, and Joy says several outlets are already playing the game. Paul wants the jury to explain how much of the game it saw. He and Drake both point to Crimson Desert as a game people played that the jury passed over. Insider Gaming reported that reviews will likely come out early Wednesday, a day before launch, though Rockstar hasn't confirmed that.
Sources
- MovieWeb: https://movieweb.com/gta-6-the-game-awards-nominations/
- Variety: https://variety.com/2026/awards/news/game-awards-nominations-2026-list-1236949480/
- ComicBook.com: https://comicbook.com/gaming/news/gta-6-just-got-nominated-for-game-of-the-year-but-there-still-arent-any-reviews/
- PC Gamer: https://www.pcgamer.com/gaming-industry/events-conferences/we-got-8-game-awards-nominations-for-gta-6-before-gta-6/
- Push Square: https://www.pushsquare.com/news/2026/11/the-game-awards-2026-nominees-revealed-gta-6-up-for-8-awards
- Make Tech Easier: https://maketecheasier.com/gta-6-game-awards-nominations-manni-l-perez/
- Gurugamer: https://gurugamer.com/pc-console/the-game-awards-2026-nominations-face-credibility-backlash-27592
- ThePCEnthusiast: https://thepcenthusiast.com/gta-6-game-awards-2026-goty-nominations/
- Metacritic: https://www.metacritic.com/game/grand-theft-auto-vi/
- Insider Gaming: https://insider-gaming.com/grand-theft-auto-6-review-embargo/
- eGamers: https://egamers.io/gta-6-review-embargo-reportedly-lifts-november-18th-but-some-outlets-may-wait-until-launch/