A federal jury in Los Angeles on Friday convicted Jonathan Rinderknecht, 30, of starting the fire that became the 2025 Palisades Fire. Prosecutors say he lit a small blaze, the Lachman Fire, just after midnight on Jan. 1, 2025. Firefighters put it out. But it kept smoldering underground, and on Jan. 7 Santa Ana winds brought it back. The Palisades Fire killed 12 people and destroyed 6,837 homes, businesses and other structures. No one else has been charged in either of the two big Los Angeles fires that started Jan. 7. Jurors convicted him on both counts, one covering the Lachman Fire and one covering the Palisades Fire. Each count carries five to 20 years in prison, and sentencing is set for March 17, 2027. Thousands of victims are separately suing the city and state, which deny the claims.

Prosecutors Put Him Alone on That Hill

Prosecutors and a juror who started out voting not guilty say no one else could have lit the fire.

Prosecutors say nobody else was up there. They showed photos of his car parked at the base of the trail, plus cellphone tower data placing him on the hill. Assistant U.S. Attorney Mark Williams said fire-alert cameras showed no other cars or people heading up before the flames appeared. He also told jurors that DNA on a barbecue lighter in Rinderknecht's rental car matched Rinderknecht.

Prosecutors say he was angry and erratic that night. They backed that up with testimony from his Uber passengers and texts to his then-girlfriend. "He was mad at everything, and frustrated," Williams said. While Rinderknecht was calling 911, he asked ChatGPT, "Are you at fault if a fire is lit because of your cigarettes?" Prosecutors said he was building an alibi.

The only juror voting not guilty at first changed his mind. A juror who gave his name as Cameron said he started out as the only not-guilty vote. "No one else was on the hill that day or night, and happened to be smoking," he told reporters. He said he felt comfortable saying "without a doubt" that Rinderknecht started it.

Prosecutors said all along they'd win this. After the June mistrial, First Assistant U.S. Attorney Bill Essayli called the evidence "strong." He vowed to "retry this case before a new jury and obtain guilty verdicts on all charged counts."

But Nobody Saw Him Start It

His lawyer and jurors from the first trial say the case has always had holes.

Nobody saw the fire start. Defense attorney Steve Haney told jurors that no witness saw the Lachman Fire begin and no camera caught the ignition. He said there was no physical evidence of his client using a lighter on the brush. He said 67 lighter tests failed to show the fire would keep spreading.

The defense says the scene sat open for six days. "Six days of anyone and everyone walking across the spot the government now calls a crime scene," Haney said. Ed Nordskog, a retired L.A. County Sheriff's Department arson investigator who testified for the defense, said "it appears hundreds of people visited the scene before it was locked down."

Something else could have started it, the defense says. Haney pointed to missing cell records and a neighbor who saw teenagers running from the direction of the trailhead. He also pointed to witnesses who heard a bang from the direction of the hill that night. He argued fireworks could have caused the fire. He called the angry texts "evidence of the man, not evidence of the act."

Ten jurors voted to acquit in June. "There's just not enough proof. A lot of holes," a juror named Syrena said afterward. On Friday, Haney said he was disappointed but respected the jury's process. He said the defense would review its options for an appeal.

Victims Say Firefighters Let the Fire Come Back

Victims suing the city and state say firefighters left a smoldering fire behind, and a conviction doesn't change that.

The victims say the fire never should have come back. Thousands of Palisades Fire victims are suing Los Angeles and California, saying crews didn't fully put out the Lachman Fire. They also say the city left the Santa Ynez Reservoir empty. Roger Behle Jr., a lead attorney for the victims, said in February that the fire "was 100% avoidable" and that "the government failed the people of Pacific Palisades miserably." Courts have let the suits move forward.

A firefighter says he saw it smoldering. In a deposition, Los Angeles Fire Department firefighter Scott Pike said he found red-hot, smoldering material during the Jan. 2 cleanup. "I saw something, I said something and, to the best of my ability, I thought we could have done more," he said.

Jurors couldn't weigh how firefighters handled the first fire. Haney has argued for more than a year that the firefighting matters. "So why are they blaming him for whatever the Fire Department didn't do?" he told reporters in fall 2025.

The fire department was short-staffed that day, too. The department's own after-action report found that staffing on Jan. 7 fell short of its standard for extreme weather. It said the department chose not to send in more firefighters ahead of time, partly to save money.

The Palisades' councilmember says no verdict can undo the harm. City Councilmember Traci Park, who represents the Palisades, told NBC Los Angeles outside court Friday that "there is no amount of courtroom justice that will ever undo the harm that was caused."

Where This Lands

Prosecutors and one juror say the evidence put Rinderknecht alone on the hill when the fire started. His lawyer says the case was circumstantial from the start. Ten jurors voted to acquit in June. Victims suing the city and state say the Lachman Fire never should have come back, no matter who lit it. A judge will sentence Rinderknecht on March 17, and the victims' lawsuits against the city and state are still moving forward.

Sources