Critics reviewed The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping Tuesday morning. It's the sixth film in the series. It tells the origin story of Haymitch Abernathy, whom Woody Harrelson played as an adult in the original films. Australian actor Joseph Zada plays him at 16. His Games come 24 years before Katniss's. Francis Lawrence directed it, and it's based on author Suzanne Collins's 2025 novel. By midday Pacific, the film held a 69 percent score on Rotten Tomatoes from 62 reviews. That's the second-lowest in the series, ahead of only the last prequel, The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes. It has a 56 on Metacritic. Lionsgate opens it in U.S. theaters Friday.

1. The Series Is Worn Out

Several critics say the series is tired and this film exists to make money.

Several critics call it a cash grab. Guardian critic Peter Bradshaw gave it one star. He wrote that the film has "no authentic reason to exist, other than to gouge an income stream out of its fanbase." IndieWire critic Ryan Lattanzio called it "a cold cash grab" and "a dreary slog." Daily Beast critic Nick Schager said it looks like "a transparent effort to keep milking a still-profitable IP."

It feels like the same movie again. Deadline critic Damon Wise wrote that the first film "seemed fresh and even satirical" in 2012. He added, "now, though, it just feels tired." Variety critic Owen Gleiberman said the movie "essentially replays the plot of the original." Empire critic Olly Richards gave it three stars and called it "an enjoyable-enough diversion, but essentially a footnote with aspirations."

2. And Zada Can't Carry the Movie

These critics say Zada falls flat and the movie misses Jennifer Lawrence.

Zada doesn't draw you in. Screen Daily critic Tim Grierson wrote that Zada "fails to captivate." He said the film "badly needs a protagonist as compelling as Katniss Everdeen — or a screen presence as singular as Jennifer Lawrence." Schager called Zada's performance "featureless." The Times of London's chief film critic, Kevin Maher, called Zada "perfunctory."

The movie misses Jennifer Lawrence. New York Times critic Brandon Yu wrote that "one really misses the guiding presence of Jennifer Lawrence." Lattanzio said Zada's performance is "charming enough." But he said the character lacks the "gravitational charisma or arc" Lawrence brought to the original films.

3. But Zada Is a Breakout, and It's the Best One in Years

Other major critics say Zada is the reason to see it.

Other critics call Zada a breakout. Hollywood Reporter critic David Rooney called Zada "the surprise asset" of the film. He called it "a breakout performance." IGN critic Tara Bennett said his Haymitch ranks with Lawrence's Katniss and Donald Sutherland's Snow. Associated Press critic Mark Kennedy called him "awesome."

It's the best since Catching Fire. TheWrap critic William Bibbiani said it earns the title of the best Hunger Games film since Catching Fire. He wrote that it "may even be the 'Hunger Games' that holds up best." Time Out critic Phil de Semlyen gave it four stars and called it "as strong as any of the five movies so far." Rooney called it a return "to the spirit of the first movies."

4. Its Warning About Tyranny Feels More Urgent Now

Some critics say the film's politics feel more urgent now.

It shows how people in power keep it. RogerEbert.com critic Matt Zoller Seitz wrote that the film is "smart and unmerciful in showing the mechanisms of power." He called it "a nasty movie for a nasty time." Bennett wrote that the films warn younger viewers "how quickly fascism can creep out of the pages of history and speculative science fiction into real life." Collins has said she drew on philosopher David Hume's idea of "implicit submission." She said the story took "a deeper dive into the use of propaganda."

The real world looks more like Panem now. Den of Geek critic David Crow wrote that the world Collins first imagined in 2008 "has become a lot less farfetched or abstract in the past 18 years." He said the film's theme of resistance "gives Sunrise a soul."

5. But One Editor Loved It, and Presales Are Strong

CinemaBlend's managing editor says the harsh reviews miss the point. Advance ticket sales were strong before the reviews came out.

One editor felt like she saw a different movie. CinemaBlend managing editor Jessica Rawden answered the Guardian and IndieWire pans directly. She wrote, "I feel like I watched a completely different movie." She also wrote that the film "emotionally wrecked" her.

It's on track for a huge opening. Deadline reported Nov. 6 that advance ticket sales were "well ahead" of Wicked's. Deadline said it should open to at least $80 million. Variety said Sunday the film is expected to open above $100 million. The last prequel opened to $44.6 million.

Where This Lands

Bradshaw, Lattanzio and Schager say this film exists for the money, and Wise says the formula feels tired. Grierson says Zada fails to captivate, and Yu says the film really misses Jennifer Lawrence. Rooney and Bennett say Zada is a breakout, and Bibbiani and de Semlyen rank the film with the series' best. Seitz and Crow say its warning about tyranny feels more urgent now, and Bennett says the series has long warned young viewers about fascism. Rawden says she saw "a completely different movie" from the critics who panned it. Box-office tracking points to an opening of $80 million or more.

Sources