The TV series The Chosen posted a 22-second teaser on X for its sixth season on Sunday, November 1, with the caption "Season 6 is different." The clip shows Jesus, played by Jonathan Roumie, in the Garden of Gethsemane as soldiers arrive to arrest him. Three bluish angelic warriors run up the walls carrying a bow, a spear and a sword. One wears a feather and looks like a Native American warrior. The other two look East Asian and African. Jesus shakes his head, and they stand down. The clip has drawn about 7 million impressions on X. Critics called the angels unbiblical and compared them to the aliens in Avatar. On Tuesday, November 3, creator and director Dallas Jenkins answered on Facebook: "Some people make 'certainty' an idol." The first three episodes of the season will arrive on Prime Video on November 15.
1. The Angels Aren't Biblical, and This Is Forced Diversity (Jon Root, Protestia, @hayasaka_aryan)
Some critics say the show used a Gospel scene to make a point about diversity.
Nothing in the Bible puts a Native American warrior in Gethsemane. Conservative commentator Jon Root posted, "Please tell me this is a joke," and asked, "Angels are Native American warriors according to The Chosen?" His post drew thousands of likes. Root also reposted a 2024 thread in which he said the show "preaches a different Gospel."
Critics say the angels look like movie creatures. Protestia, a popular Christian account on X, compared the angels to the blue creatures in James Cameron's Avatar. Its own write-up describes them as "a Black woman, a small Asian man/boy, and a Native American-looking 'Avatar' creature." One X user joked about the part of "St. Luke's Gospel where the orcs crossed with Avatar aliens tried to ambush the Lord." Others said the scene looked like something out of Twilight.
Some critics say the diversity is the point, and that's the problem. The X user @hayasaka_aryan wrote that a show about Jesus had Native Americans added to it, and that "not even Jesus is safe from forced diversity."
A smaller group thinks it's a Mormon reference. One X user called the scene a "theological easter egg for mormons," and others called the angels "Nephites." The Book of Mormon says the Nephites were Hebrews who traveled to the Americas about 600 years before Christ. Latter-day Saints founded Angel Studios, which distributed the show early on. Two of the show's executive producers, Derral Eves and Brad Pelo, remain affiliated with Mormonism. Jenkins has said the show is "not even .1 percent" influenced by Mormon theology.
2. But the Bible Never Said Angels Have Wings and Halos (Paul Tassi, fans citing Matthew 26)
This camp says the winged, haloed angel isn't in the Bible either.
Scripture describes angels in all kinds of forms. Forbes senior contributor Paul Tassi writes that angels "with two feathery wings and gold halos and robes and harps are not really described in the Bible at all," and that "there could be warrior angels taking the form of human fighters across time." He sums it up: "there are a whole lot of different types of angels."
The scene comes straight from Matthew. At his arrest, Jesus says he could call on his Father for "more than twelve legions of angels." The verse says nothing about what they look like. Fans pointed to the same passage. Another defender wrote on X that God's angels "have been working alongside humans from the very beginning" and "can look however God wants them to."
3. Jenkins Says the Critics Haven't Watched It, and Wanting to Be Sure Is Its Own Idol (Dallas Jenkins)
Jenkins says the critics are sure about things they can't know.
He says needing to be certain is its own kind of idol. In his Tuesday Facebook post, Jenkins wrote that certainty about love and "God's authority and Truth" is good. "But for some folks, the need for certainty expands to everything. And they nearly always value certainty over curiosity." He said the number of people with firm conclusions about "what supernatural beings are supposed to look like, is astonishing." Anyone who claims to know what they're seeing without watching the episode, he wrote, "should be seriously questioned. Or ignored."
He says he doesn't know what angels look like either. "I have no idea how accurate my depiction of supernatural beings (I show multiple) is this season," he wrote. "I just know the majority of the initial haters have even less of an idea than I do. But certainty is their idol." He asked people to keep debating but "to prioritize curiosity as you do it." Crosswalk reported that a few fans who had already seen the full episode said the scene made more sense in context.
He's argued about idolatry before, in his own defense. In 2023, pastor and author Voddie Baucham said The Chosen violates the Second Commandment. Jenkins replied that the commandment covers "objects of worship" and that "no one is worshiping the TV screen." This week he used the charge against his critics.
Where This Lands
Root asks whether the Native American angels are a joke, and Protestia says they look like Avatar creatures. Others in their camp say the show cast them that way to make a point about diversity. Tassi and the fans quoting Matthew say the Bible never spelled out what angels look like. They say the critics are defending an image the Bible never gave them. Jenkins says the critics haven't watched the episode. He doesn't claim to know what angels look like himself, and he says insisting you do know is the real idolatry. The first three episodes will arrive on Prime Video on November 15.
Sources
- Christian Post: https://www.christianpost.com/news/dallas-jenkins-responds-to-backlash-at-angels-in-the-chosen.html
- ChurchLeaders: https://churchleaders.com/news/2225133-dallas-jenkins-the-chosen-season-6-teaser-certainty-idol.html
- ChurchLeaders: https://churchleaders.com/news/2224952-the-chosen-angels-native-american.html
- Crosswalk: https://www.crosswalk.com/headlines/contributors/michael-foust/the-chosen-clip-of-angels-ready-to-rescue-jesus-ignites-online-debate.html
- Forbes via Yahoo Entertainment: https://www.yahoo.com/entertainment/tv/articles/chosen-season-6-upsets-fans-142813781.html
- Jubileecast: https://www.jubileecast.com/articles/40830/20261104/dallas-jenkins-responds-to-backlash-over-angels-in-the-chosen-season-6-teaser.htm
- Jubileecast: https://www.jubileecast.com/articles/40766/20261102/the-chosen-season-6-teaser-divides-viewers-over-angels-resembling-native-american-warriors.htm
- Protestia: https://protestia.substack.com/p/guardians-of-gethsemane-the-chosen
- Jon Root on X: https://x.com/JonnyRoot_/status/2117100638673027535
- The Chosen on X: https://x.com/thechosentv/status/2117030123660579112
- Christian Post: https://www.christianpost.com/news/chosen-creator-responds-to-voddie-baucham-criticism.html