On Saturday, Iowa State said it has started "enhanced monitoring" of its women's basketball program. A day earlier, six former players sent the school a letter accusing coach Bill Fennelly of "verbal, emotional, and psychological abuse." The letter came five days after a game against UIC on Nov. 15. During a late timeout, Fennelly yelled at sophomore guard Sienna Harvey, then put his hand on her head and pushed. Video of the moment spread online. Athletic director Jared Benko suspended him for one game that night, and Fennelly apologized. He sat out Wednesday's game at Northern Iowa. Fennelly is 69 and in his 32nd season at Iowa State. He has said this one will be his last. He's scheduled to coach again Sunday when Iowa State hosts Drake.
The Ex-Players Say the Push Was Part of a Long Pattern
These former players say Iowa State didn't take their complaints seriously and needs an outside review.
They say the video showed something familiar. The suspension "has renewed attention to conduct that in our opinion reflects a longstanding problem," the players wrote. They described "an environment where intimidation, humiliation, and fear became normalized." Two of them signed their names: Maggie Espenmiller-McGraw, who played at Iowa State from 2019 to 2023, and Izabella Zingaro, who arrived in 2020. Both later transferred. Four others signed anonymously.
They say they complained and weren't taken seriously. The players wrote that they told coaches and athletics administrators about what they considered abuse, and about what they saw as inappropriate physical contact. "We do not believe our concerns were taken seriously," they wrote. They also said the harm lasted. Some still deal with "anxiety, depression, diminished self-worth, and lasting distress" they tie to their time in the program.
They say they accepted hard coaching, but not abuse. "We accepted the demands of hard work, discipline, and competitive excellence," they wrote. "But demanding excellence is fundamentally different from undermining an athlete's dignity, well-being, and sense of safety."
They want an outside review, not an internal one. The letter asks for "an independent, trauma-informed review" of the program and how the school handled complaints. That review would also look at what officials knew. The players also want protection from retaliation and a confidential way for athletes to speak up. Des Moines attorney Lori Bullock represents them. She told the Des Moines Register they're "looking into everything" when it comes to legal options. A spokesperson for the group told USA TODAY Sports they aren't considering legal action at this time.
But His Current Players Say He Coaches Hard Because He Cares
These players and defenders say the viral clip was misread and the suspension went too far.
The player he pushed is defending him. "I can see how it was perceived on the internet," Harvey said after Wednesday's game. "But, he loves us and cares about us more than anyone. And I like being coached hard." Teammate Mya Babbitt backed her up. "He's a great person on and off the court, and he cares about us so much," Babbitt said.
A WNBA player says the suspension itself was soft. Indiana Fever guard Sophie Cunningham said on her podcast that she watched the clip and "did not think anything was wrong with it." She read it as a coach getting on a player who wasn't locked in. "I think this is soft," she said. "Zero percent of me agrees with this."
He apologized, but he won't apologize for who he is. Fennelly talked to reporters Friday for the first time since the suspension. "You're human. You're going to make mistakes," he said, quoting his parents. "When you make it, you're accountable for it." He also said: "I am who I am, I'm not gonna apologize for that. Our kids know how much I love them." He hasn't addressed the letter itself in any report. He didn't immediately respond to The Athletic's request for comment Saturday.
And Iowa State Says Its Own Process Can Handle It
The school says it takes the claims seriously and is watching the team, but it hasn't promised an outside review.
The school punished the push right away. Benko suspended Fennelly the same night. "We cannot tolerate inappropriate contact between a coach or staff member and a student-athlete in practice or in competition, whether intentional or not," he said. Benko only took over as athletic director in October.
On the letter, the school is moving more slowly. Iowa State's statement says it "takes seriously any claims of conduct contrary to our values and standards." It says the school already "has appropriate policies and procedures in place" for misconduct claims. Iowa State has contacted the players' lawyer "to try and ascertain details of their general claims." The statement doesn't mention an independent review.
Nobody has said what "enhanced monitoring" means. The school says the monitoring is meant to support players "as well as Coach Fennelly and his coaching staff." The statement didn't spell out any new steps. Iowa State didn't immediately answer The Athletic's question about what the monitoring involves.
Where This Lands
The former players say Fennelly's push fit a long pattern, and they want an outside review of how Iowa State handled their complaints. His current players say he's a demanding coach who cares about them, and Cunningham thinks even the suspension went too far. Iowa State says its own policies can handle the claims, and for now it's watching the team without promising an outside review. Fennelly is set to coach Sunday against Drake in what he's said is his final season.
Sources
- Des Moines Register (via Yahoo): https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/former-iowa-state-players-accuse-230854161.html
- Des Moines Register (via Yahoo): https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/iowa-state-responds-former-womens-224903424.html
- The Athletic (via Yahoo): https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/iowa-state-responds-women-basketball-023104981.html
- ESPN: https://www.espn.com/womens-college-basketball/story/_/id/50556995/iowa-state-addresses-ex-players-allegations-bill-fennelly
- USA TODAY Sports (via Yahoo): https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/ex-iowa-state-women-basketball-223749144.html
- Yahoo Sports: https://sports.yahoo.com/womens-college-basketball/article/former-iowa-state-womens-basketball-players-call-for-independent-review-of-head-coach-bill-fennelly-citing-verbal-emotional-and-psychological-abuse-032919971.html
- KCCI: https://www.kcci.com/article/iowa-state-womens-basketball-players-call-for-independent-review-bill-fennelly/74494528
- The Times of Ankeny: https://thetimesofankeny.substack.com/p/six-former-iowa-state-womens-basketball
- EssentiallySports: https://www.essentiallysports.com/wnba-basketball-news-nothing-was-wrong-with-it-sophie-cunninghams-bill-fennelly-take-contrasts-with-6-former-players-demands/
- EssentiallySports (via Yahoo): https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/bill-fennelly-speaks-first-time-024516774.html
- Just Women's Sports: https://justwomenssports.com/?p=43369