Cricket Australia's board gave Pat Cummins its "unanimous support" as captain on Saturday. The board met after weeks of pressure over the 2018 Cape Town Test, when batter Cameron Bancroft got caught using sandpaper on the ball. Cricket Australia punished only Bancroft, captain Steve Smith and vice-captain David Warner. This month, former batter Usman Khawaja's memoir said the whole team knew. On Wednesday, Bancroft backed Khawaja's account in a statement of more than 4,000 words in The West Australian. Cummins bowled in that Test. Last week, in a 68-minute news conference, he denied knowing anything. Interim chair David Boon and CEO Todd Greenberg met him in Sydney on Friday. On Saturday, former coach Darren Lehmann denied Bancroft's claims about him. Cummins is due to lead Australia against New Zealand in Perth on Dec. 9.

His Captaincy Can't Survive This

Former players and pundits say the bowlers must have known, and Cummins should go.

The bowlers must have known. BBC chief cricket commentator Jonathan Agnew, a former bowler, says it has never seemed "remotely plausible" that they didn't. He argues a batter wouldn't work on the ball without a bowler knowing. Bancroft says the bowlers told him whether what he was doing to the ball was working.

The pressure to quit will be too much. Former Australia fast bowler Mitchell Johnson wrote in The West Australian that he believes Bancroft. He says the public pressure to stand down "will be too much." Broadcaster Piers Morgan told Nine's Today show, "Cummins has to go." A Code Sports reader poll found 72% of more than 10,000 readers said he shouldn't stay.

He could quit without admitting anything. Agnew wrote that Cummins' "way out could be to resign, without admitting guilt." He says the crowd's reaction in Perth will be the real test. Johnson, Morgan and Agnew all spoke out before the board met.

But He's Done Nothing Wrong, and He Stays

The board, a fellow bowler and his manager say Cummins' story holds up.

His account hasn't changed, so he stays captain. "Nothing's changed. Thus, nothing's changing with our captaincy," Greenberg told BBC Sport. He said he isn't putting one person's version of events over another's. Boon said the board "unequivocally" rejects any suggestion that Cummins' integrity has been compromised.

A fellow bowler says he didn't know. Fast bowler Josh Hazlewood also played in Cape Town. He says he wasn't an architect of the plan and didn't know anyone was using sandpaper. He called the last few days "a bit of a pile-on." Asked if he'd rethink his own future if Cummins lost the captaincy, he said, "you'd have to think about it."

There's no case against him. Cummins' manager, Neil Maxwell, called the resignation calls "hysteria unfounded in reality." He says there's no serious case that Cummins planned the tampering or knew sandpaper was on the field.

And the 2018 Investigation Is the Real Problem

These critics say Cricket Australia's 2018 investigation failed, and its new forum for players' stories won't fix that.

Investigators may have skipped three of the bowlers in 2018. As far as Warner knows, Cricket Australia never interviewed Hazlewood or fellow bowlers Mitchell Starc and Nathan Lyon in 2018. "If that's correct, then how can CA push the idea that the bowlers didn't know?" he said. Bancroft now says he didn't give investigators a full account back then.

Look at the coaches first. Guardian cricket writer Geoff Lemon says anyone looking into this should first skip the bowlers and "start at the top, with the tour's coaches." He thinks the time for formal punishment has passed. He calls the board's new forum inadequate because it's voluntary and private. A senior lawyer or former judge will run it, and it won't hand out new punishments.

Only a real inquiry will settle it. SEN broadcaster Gerard Whateley wants a judicial inquiry, "a little bit like a coroner's inquest." Witnesses would have to attend and face cross-examination. Cricket Australia has insisted it won't reopen its investigation.

Or It's Eight Years Old and Blown Out of Proportion

A columnist and the former coach say the reaction has gone too far.

This got bigger than it ever should have. Guardian writer Jonathan Horn says the story "should never have been allowed to get as big as it did." He says calls for inquests ignore "the realities of dressing rooms, of human frailty, even of memory."

Everyone should move on. Lehmann still says he didn't know about the sandpaper. "But you've just got to try and move on," he said on Saturday.

Where This Lands

Cricket Australia says Cummins' story hasn't changed, so its captain won't either. Agnew says the bowlers must have known, and Johnson says Cummins' captaincy can't survive this. Warner and Lemon say Cricket Australia's own 2018 investigation failed. Horn and Lehmann want everyone to move on. Cummins says he'll take part in the forum. He says his focus now is leading the team in Perth.

Sources