The Detroit Lions beat the New England Patriots 35-10 in Munich on Sunday. On the Patriots' first drive, Lions defensive end Aidan Hutchinson sacked quarterback Drake Maye from behind on third-and-goal. Maye hurt his right ankle on the play and didn't return. Hutchinson leapt to celebrate, and his right knee buckled when he landed. The Lions ruled him out too. NFL Network reports the Lions fear a significant knee injury. Reporter Tom Pelissero reports it will end his season. The Lions haven't confirmed a diagnosis. Referees threw no flag on the sack.
Some Analysts Say It Was an Illegal Hip-Drop
Fox's Greg Olsen called it a hip-drop that could still draw a fine, and plenty of fans agreed.
Critics say the sack looked like the tackle the NFL banned. The league outlawed the hip-drop tackle in 2024. Heavy reports that Olsen, a Fox analyst, said on the broadcast that the sack looked like a hip-drop that went without a flag. He said it could still draw a fine. Replay showed Hutchinson's right calf landing on Maye's ankle. Front Office Sports reporter Mark Maske wrote on X that "there did seem to be some of those elements." He added that all of the elements must be there for the tackle to be illegal.
Plenty of fans blasted the no-call. AOL reports "widespread criticism from analysts, reporters and fans" after the no-call. "Refs genuinely don't call hip drop tackles anymore I think they forgot," one fan wrote on X.
But the NFL Says the Tackle Was Legal
The league and Fox's rules expert say the sack didn't meet the rule, and the Patriots' coach called it part of the game.
It didn't meet two of the three conditions Pereira listed. Fox rules analyst Mike Pereira said on the broadcast that it was "not a hip-drop." "You have to unweight yourself, swivel all around the back, and land on the back of his legs below the knee," he said. He said it was "more of a horse collar type, pulled down from behind," but it wasn't a horse-collar foul. The NFL's officiating rules analyst, Walt Anderson, backed him through a league spokesman. Anderson said there was no swivel and no unweighting. He also said Hutchinson never grabbed Maye's collar.
Even the Patriots' coach called it part of the game. "However it happened, I don't think it was anything intentional. It's just part of the game," Patriots coach Mike Vrabel said. Heavy writer Dan Morrison wrote that Patriots fans likely won't agree with Pereira, but "by the letter of the law, he's right." AOL suggested Hutchinson's one-arm grip may have kept officials from calling a foul. But the NFL rewrote the rule in 2025 to cover a grab with one hand, ProFootballTalk reported.
A Former Lion Says Hutchinson Didn't Need to Leap
A former Lions guard says players should stop leaving their feet to celebrate.
The star pass rusher got hurt after the play was over. Former Lions guard T.J. Lang posted on X, "I know it's a freak injury. I know the adrenaline is pumping. Players need to stop leaving their feet while celebrating." Hutchinson led the NFL in pressures through nine weeks. He's also two years removed from a broken leg that cost him most of 2024.
His knee may have been hurt already. ProFootballTalk's Mike Florio wrote that it was a non-contact injury. He wrote that if the ACL is fully torn, it may already have been partly torn, "unbeknownst to Hutchinson or the Lions." Lions coach Dan Campbell had "nothing new" on the injury after the game. "Any time you lose a player of his caliber... that doesn't make things easy," he said.
Where This Lands
Olsen says the sack looked like a hip-drop and could still draw a fine. Pereira and the NFL's Anderson say it didn't meet the rule, and Vrabel called it part of the game. Lang says players should stop leaving their feet to celebrate. Maye will get more tests. The Patriots head into their bye at 5-5. The Lions are 7-2 and host Tampa Bay next Sunday.
Sources
- ESPN: https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/50492387/patriots-qb-drake-maye-testing-ankle-injury
- Boston Globe: https://www.bostonglobe.com/2026/11/15/sports/drake-maye-patriots/
- Bleacher Report: https://bleacherreport.com/articles/25533757-aidan-hutchinsons-hit-drake-maye-injured-patriots-qb-addressed-nfl-rules-expert
- Heavy (Pereira and Olsen): https://heavy.com/sports/nfl/new-england-patriots/expert-hip-drop-injured-drake-maye/
- Heavy (T.J. Lang): https://heavy.com/sports/nfl/detroit-lions/former-lions-captain-calls-out-aidan-hutchinson/
- ProFootballTalk: https://www.nbcsports.com/nfl/profootballtalk/rumor-mill/news/aidan-hutchinson-reportedly-has-significant-knee-injury
- CBS Sports: https://www.cbssports.com/nfl/news/lions-aidan-hutchinson-injury-update-patriots-germany/
- Pride of Detroit: https://www.prideofdetroit.com/detroit-lions-news/181118/aidan-hutchinson-suffers-injury-sack-celebration-updates
- AOL: https://www.aol.com/articles/nfl-referees-called-missing-hip-162942000.html
- Yahoo Sports: https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/calls-mount-against-nfl-refs-184446112.html
- ProFootballTalk (2025 rule change): https://www.nbcsports.com/nfl/profootballtalk/rumor-mill/news/nfl-tweaks-definition-of-hip-drop-tackle-allowing-for-more-fines-in-2025