Van Gogh painted Châtaigniers en fleurs ("Chestnut Trees in Blossom") in 1890. Sotheby's estimates it at about $180 million, which would beat the artist's auction record of $117.2 million. It's the top lot in a 12-painting sale. The paintings come from the collection of the late Argentine collectors Nelly Arrieta de Blaquier and Carlos Pedro Blaquier, and their children are selling. The sale is set for 6 p.m. Eastern on Wednesday in New York. Sotheby's has guaranteed the sellers a minimum price. Samuel Fischer, the German Jewish publisher, bought the painting in 1909. His family left it with an Amsterdam dealer in 1932 or 1933, and the dealer sold it to a Paris couple in 1936. On Friday, The New York Times reported that Fischer's heirs want Sotheby's to pull it from the sale. Sotheby's hasn't said whether the painting will still be offered Wednesday.

It Was a Forced Sale, So Sotheby's Should Pull It

The Fischer heirs say the Nazis drove the 1936 sale, and the auction house has to prove otherwise.

The family sold because the Nazis were ruining them. Gunnar Schnabel, a Berlin lawyer for the heirs, says the family sold in 1936 because of the losses the Nazis inflicted on its publishing house. That company published Thomas Mann and Hermann Hesse. The Nazis banned many of its authors. Schnabel says the sale happened three months after the family left Berlin for Vienna. He says the family also had to pay the Reich flight tax. The Nazis used that emigration tax to strip Jews of their assets as they left.

It's on the auction house to prove this was a fair sale. In a Nov. 12 email, Schnabel told Sotheby's restitution chief, Marco Toracca, that "no auction may take place" unless the house proves the 1936 sale was at true market value. He also wants proof the family would have sold the painting even without Nazi rule. He says the heirs will still work toward a fair solution under the 1998 Washington Principles. Those are the international guidelines for art lost to Nazi persecution.

The law used to ignore sales like this one. After the war, Samuel's son-in-law, Gottfried Bermann Fischer, got his publishing company back. He also sought compensation for what the Nazis took. He didn't try to reclaim the paintings sold in Amsterdam. At the time, the law gave no basis for compensation for art sold outside Nazi-ruled territory. In 1936, the Netherlands was outside that territory. That has changed. In June 2025, the Kunstmuseum Bern gave up a Sisley. A persecuted Jewish collector had sold it in Switzerland in 1940. The museum said the sale traced back to Nazi persecution.

The family warned years ago that it might object. The New York Times reported that in 2007, Christie's offered a Fischer family Cézanne. That painting had also been left with the same Amsterdam dealer and sold in 1936. Gottfried's daughter, Gisela Bermann Fischer, didn't object to that sale. But in her letter to Christie's, she reserved the right to object in the future over any other painting her father sold under duress because of Nazi persecution.

But Sotheby's Found No Proof of Duress

The auction house says its research doesn't back the claim, though it wants to settle with the family.

The records don't show a forced sale. The auction house told the BBC it "has undertaken extensive research into the ownership history" of the painting. It said it's "committed to working toward a mutually satisfactory resolution," even though "our research to date has not established that the painting was sold under duress."

The house has published the painting's ownership history. Sotheby's catalogue traces it back to 1890 and says the Fischers left it with the dealer Walter Feilchenfeldt in 1932 or 1933. Sotheby's says it has been talking with the heirs' representatives about the painting's history.

And the Sellers Bought It in Good Faith Back in 1975

The Blaquier family says it has owned the painting in good faith for 50 years, and the heirs never brought it a claim.

They bought it honestly from a major gallery. In a statement to the Argentine newspaper La Nación, the Blaquier family said it is the painting's legitimate owner and has been for more than 50 years. Nelly Arrieta de Blaquier bought it in 1975. The family says it bought the work in good faith from a top international gallery.

They say the heirs never asked them for it. The family says the Fischer heirs never made any claim to it, formal or informal, in all the decades it owned the work. It says the painting went on public display several times over the years.

The family will still talk. The Blaquiers say there's no evidence of a sale under duress. They also say they're open to a dialogue with the heirs and support a fair solution.

Where This Lands

The Fischer heirs say the Nazis forced the 1936 sale, and they want the painting pulled unless Sotheby's can prove otherwise. Sotheby's says its research hasn't shown duress, but it wants to settle with the family. The Blaquier family says it bought the painting in good faith in 1975, and the Fischer heirs never raised a claim with it. All three sides say they'll keep talking. The sale is still set for Wednesday night.

Sources